Drive-By-Wire

Posted by murmini Sat, 23 Sep 2006 13:29:39 GMT

The throttle pedal in the MINI is just yet another reminder of the BMW connection that MINIs have. That reassuring underpinning of BMW tried and tested performance technology from which we benefit.

The gas pedal on many cars connects with the throttle body via either a metal linkage, or a flexible steel wire (just like a brake cable on a bicycle). When you step on the gas it opens the throttle and allows more air to flow into the engine, (probably should be called the air pedal) in turn, the engine demands more gas and the engine goes faster. With the advent of fuel injection the engine management system sees the throttle open via a throttle position sensor and instructs the fuel injectors to provide more gas with the same overall effect.

The standard throttle linkage is prone to issues effecting it's general overall reliability that can result in a lack of responsiveness. If it snaps your engine is going to be stuck at idle, if it sticks open, then its white knuckle driving until you can turn off the engine. (see remark below!) It is also prone to the linkage wearing out, becoming sluggish due to lack of lubrication and so forth. It is a mechanical device prone to the ailments of all mechanized things.

For some time now, BMW has been employing a 'drive-by-wire' technology that converts the motion of the throttle pedal to a signal that the Engine Control Module (ECM) computer can use to determine how much throttle is being depressed and how fast you depressed it.

Mini Gas PedalPicture 1-1

The MINI gas pedal, shown above (with BMW Group identifier) has no physical connection to the throttle body. It is a stand alone device with a 6 pin electronic connection. Simply, it is a device that converts the spring-loaded up/down action of the throttle pedal into a rotary action. This rotary action is measured or gauged by a Hall Effect sensor that converts the motion (and subsequent position) into a voltage signal almost like a volume control determines how loud a radio is. Below is a view of the box containing the two Hall Effect devices and the 6 pin connector.
Hall Effect Box
Now, just in case your overtaking a car one day and your worrying if this thing might fail, they have built in a level of redundancy and subsequently made this gadget extra safe. I mean, after all, it's your 'go fast' pedal! The extra level of redundancy is incorporated by using two hall effect devices on the rotational shaft evident by the six pin connector on the throttle pedal assembly. A five volt input/output and ground drives one hall effect device or throttle pedal sensor and a second, completely independent 2 volt input/output and ground provided by a completely separate circuit, drives the other one. This acts as a redundant system seeing a drivers request for 'more gas' and a 'plausibility check from the second or backup sensor. The following diagram is a very simplified version of what is going on.
Ecu
Its a clever system that constantly monitors both throttle position, 'how fast you want to go' and rate of throttle opening, 'how fast you want to get to that speed' . The signals received from this are processed by the ECM and subsequent required quantities of air and fuel are calculated and delivered by opening the throttle body (air) and by opening the fuel injectors (gas) accordingly.

Many other devices are also providing simultaneous data to the ECM such as the TMAP (Temperature and Manifold Absolute Pressure) sensor and the Manifold Air Pressure MAP sensor informing engine management of the ambient conditions. Additional devices also deliver data input, like the camshaft positioning sensor which assists in providing the synchronization necessary to fire the ignition spark and burst of injected fuel at the critical moment.

This is certainly more reliable than the traditional throttle cable; a piece of flexible, braided steel wire, within a plastic sleeve, that ran from the throttle peddle, through the firewall into the engine compartment, to the throttle body. I recall in an early 1970's mini I used to own, where the engine grounding was so bad that every time I started the engine, a good load of amps found their way down the throttle cable, sufficient anyway to heat it up to a point where the plastic housing would melt and cause a recurring sticky throttle cable. A problem that took a while to solve. Believe me, sticky throttle cables can be quite alarming!

12 comments

Comments

  1. Taylor said about 12 hours later:

    Thanks for posting this Murray! Superbly informative and interesting.

  2. blalor said about 21 hours later:

    Have you figured out how position feedback is sent through the pedal to the driver’s foot? For example. when you disengage the cruise control, you can feel the pedal rise slightly under your food. I’ve wondered how they do that with the drive-by-wire system.

  3. murmini said 1 day later:

    I find this a bit intriguing – the two voltage feeds, after passing through the Hall Effect circuits are fed to the ECM as INPUTS. I do not see any output from the engine control module being fed back to the pedal as a ‘response’, in fact the only OUTPUT from the Air Management part of the ECM is to the motor-driven throttle valve. The pedal acts as a dual sensor in the same way as the camshaft sensor and so on. Cruise Control is not managed by Air Management because it has to look for specific signals from the brake pedal switch, clutch switch, vehicle speed sensor as well as digital instructions from the steering wheel such as: slow down, speed up, set, resume, as INPUTS. A car not empoying drive-by-wire would probably provide pedal feedback as the cruise control would be activating the throttle and would therfore be connected to the pedal. Can you describe actually what takes place and maybe what year the car is?

  4. Paul said 7 days later:

    Great article! By wire systems are really interesting. My HCI masters project last year was on the effects related to the lack of physical or haptic feedback in by wire systems. I fear that within the decade, if not sooner, we’ll really see a big push towards steering by wire in cars. I know it’s all in the name of safety, but we’re not flying inherently unstable aircraft here ;)

  5. Antonio Catalá Meyer said 8 months later:

    Me gustaria que me pueda alludar con la coneccion de el blow off ya el mini cooper s 2007 ya que vino turbo yo le instale el blowe off y me falta cenectar la manga de vaquium o vacuum del blow off al throttle o a algun lado pero nose donde ponertla mi mail es catalaantonio@yahoo.com, catalameyer@yahoo.com o a mi cel (787) 644-2343 y le agradecere mucho gracias Antonio Catala o que Me consigan el diagrama del throtle body de este mini cooper 2007 GRCIAS

  6. murmini said 8 months later:

    Gracias para su mensaje. Quisiera ayudarte , pero no tengo un diagrama para el mini cooper 2007. Pienso que tu necesitas preguntar el sito de web mini2.com, con esta misma pregunta.

    Otra vez, gracias para su mensaje. Saludos,

  7. El agus said about 1 year later:

    Mini cooper S 2002, se prenden las luces de la direccion y el ELS y deja de inyectar, ya lo arreglaron 2 veces y sigue fallando intermitentemente puede ser el TPS?

  8. Dave said about 1 year later:

    Great article. Could you please tell me which wires are ground, and which are 5 and 2 volts? I have one of these throttles, and want to use it in an electric car.

  9. murmini said about 1 year later:

    Dave: I will do some research…

  10. Alex said over 2 years later:

    olá

    gostaria que me ajudam-se a descobrir a avaria do meu Mini One modelo europeu 2001.

    ele perde a aceleração quando ando abaixo das 2000 R/P. acima das 2000 r/p não tem problema com a aceleração. que sensores devo trocar e quais os p/n? poderiam dizer-me o nome e p/n do sensor que fica no motor mas na direcção ao apoio do motor do lado do passageiro.

  11. travis said over 3 years later:

    i neeeddd to find a replacement part for my 06 copper s. its the throttle position sensor/ foot pedel shown above. if anybody knows where online i can get it pleeaasee tell me.

  12. murmini said over 3 years later:

    If you can’t find a MINI one, the BMW 3 series one is the same. You may want to ask a parts dept. to match the serial numbers, but in my 05 MINI Coopers its a BMW part. Thought this might broaden your chances.

(leave url/email »)

   Comment Markup Help Preview comment